No doubt appearances are sometimes deceiving, but I have been struck, over the years, by how many of my colleagues in Leafstrewn seem to have relatively happy and healthy marriages. Most of us are married, I'm pretty sure our divorce rate is well under 10%, and the marriages generally seem strong and fulfilling. If my colleague RG's retirement book idea is "Kids These Days" (about adult disapproval through the ages), a book I always imagine writing in retirement is "Secrets to a Happy Marriage--How Leafstrewn Teachers Make Relationships Work."
A new Gallup survey makes me wonder if our happy marriages really are just due to our profession. According to Gallup, teaching "may be one of the best careers for a person’s wellbeing." Teachers rank just below doctors in overall life satisfaction, and they are the most likely of any profession to say they "smiled or laughed a lot yesterday." Teachers also ranked high in saying they get to use their strengths at their work. Interestingly, the only categories in which teachers were last were in the level of respect with which they feel they are treated and in saying that their supervisor creates a trusting and open environment. Fortunately, we here at Leafstrewn have humane and competent administrators, so we're even happier!
(Then again, could our happy marriages just be due to the fact that we Leafstrewn teachers read a lot?)
Showing posts with label Wise Colleagues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wise Colleagues. Show all posts
Monday, April 1, 2013
Friday, February 1, 2013
My colleagues and I gave a common assessment!
Amazingly enough, we did it. Every freshman at Leafstrewn was given the same two-page
passage from a Sherman Alexie story and the same prompt for an analytical
paragraph, and every paragraph was graded with the same 5-category rubric. To make the grading more objective, we
graded the exams, not of our own students, but of our colleagues’.
We will eventually sit down and consider the numbers, but I
have a few reactions now:
(1) reading a passage and writing an analysis of it is an
extraordinarily complex task, which is great, but it’s pretty hard to assess in
an objective way;
(2) the strength of rubrics is that they are specific and
explicit, but this is also their weakness;
(3) everyone got a B;
(4) that’s okay!
(5) I could have done a much better job of preparing my
students, and that preparation would have been better not just for this
assessment, but in general.
(1) Reading a passage and writing an analysis of it is an
extraordinarily complex task, which is great, but it’s pretty hard to assess in
an objective way
There is an incredible amount to keep track of when you’re
reading anything closely—emotions, connotations of particular words, figures of
speech, intertextuality, patterns (like repetition and contrast) within the
text, etc. Writing, too, is
really, really complicated—you have to master grammar, ideas, structure,
logical arguments, relevant evidence, and so on. Skilled readers and writers do all this unconsciously, and
we sometimes forget that it is amazingly complicated, and our brains, even the
most “limited” of them, are quite incredible.
This incredible
complexity becomes much more visible when you start talking about how to
judge the quality of student reading and writing. Different teachers have different ideas of which pieces of
this incredible complexity to focus on.
It’s like the story of the elephant: I’m looking at the elephant’s legs,
one colleague is looking at the trunk, another is bumping into the tusks, and
so on. Designing a rubric is
tough, because there are always things that you’re leaving out, or looking at
from only one side.
(2) The strength of rubrics is that they are specific and
explicit, but this is also their weakness
Much of the trouble in grading the assessment came in using
the rubric. A rubric is intended
to make the grading more transparent and clear, and, most crucially, more
specific. If a student is told,
“Your essay is bad,” the student will want to know what in particular was bad
about it. A rubric is supposed to
offer the kid that specificity.
What was interesting about the grading process was that the specificity
of the rubric was usually exactly what
caused trouble in the grading.
For example, if we judged that a conclusion is not good
enough for the “Good” category, we had to circle the box on the rubric for a
conclusion that “Needs Work.” That box reads: “Brings paragraph to a finish
that repeats previous ideas.” The
problem is that there are many ways for a conclusion to be bad, and repeating
previous ideas is only one of them. I ran into this problem of overly specific descriptors in
every single category on this rubric.
(3) Everyone got a B
Either because our rubric was too easy at the low end, too
tough at the high end, or because our students are all pretty good, or because
we did a good job of preparing our students, most of the grades fell in the B
range.
(4) That’s okay!
I think one of the lessons here is that actually for all our
hand-wringing, our kids are really quite competent. They can read a passage and write a reasonable paragraph
about it. They are not
illiterate. Almost all of them
managed to come up with identifiable topic sentences, evidence that more or
less supported their main ideas, and a conclusion that in some way related to
what they were saying. This is no
mean feat for a fourteen year old, and I wonder, I admit, if it has something
to do with MCAS. Maybe, as our department chair
says, MCAS has really improved kids’ ability to write these kinds of paragraphs.
(5) I could have done a much better job of preparing my
students, and that preparation would have been better not just for this
assessment, but in general!
I think this common assessment was a great thing to do. Having students read something and
analyze it in a disciplined way is worthwhile, and doing it as a group certainly made my own teaching
better. I was more focused, my
students were more motivated, and it took some of the dissonance out of the
grading. (Normally, when we grade
our own students’ work, there is an uncomfortable dissonance. It is as if Bela Karolyi were to judge
his own gymnasts’ routines, or as if a soccer coach were training his team for
a game against herself.) In a
fairly short and stress-free preparation, I think I did a reasonably good job.
Nevertheless, although my students' performance was fine, there was a lot of room for improvement. How could I have helped them more? What could I have done better?
A bunch of things, but here's one: I didn’t train my students well enough in coming up with a good main
idea. They tended to say something
like, “The impression the author creates in this impression is of a family that
is struggling.” That is pretty
obvious, and I need to help my students learn how to go deeper. To take an
obvious thought and push it deeper one may:
* Explore the why of
the obvious thought (e.g. the family struggles because they’re in denial).
* Consider ways in which the opposite is true as well, and
craft a semi-dialectical topic sentence of the "Although A, nevertheless B" type--and then by the end of their paper they may arrive at the synthesis of C. Later in life they can worry, Mr. Ramsay-like, about getting to Q or Z.
* Explore the how of
the obvious thought (e.g. the family struggles ineffectually, trying the same
things over and over again even though they produce no results (father looking
in wallet over and over, son dreaming over and over, etc.))
* Are there other ways? Applying a schema? Making a connection? What else?
Teaching my students to push their thinking further would be useful not merely for the exam, but in general. This is something that would be useful to focus on explicitly, and that I somehow overlooked. That is one of the virtues of this common assessment--it makes the whole process more conscious and transparent, and so lets us see things that we should have seen before.
* Are there other ways? Applying a schema? Making a connection? What else?
Teaching my students to push their thinking further would be useful not merely for the exam, but in general. This is something that would be useful to focus on explicitly, and that I somehow overlooked. That is one of the virtues of this common assessment--it makes the whole process more conscious and transparent, and so lets us see things that we should have seen before.
In the end, though, we and our students did a fine job. Now if we could just get them to like to read...
Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Teachers, Instruction, Relationships
(A quick post--I'm thinking through these issues--the brain surgery analogy makes sense to me, though it may come out of left field for some other people... Also, I'm not sure why the font switches size or style--I wrote it all out at the same time, I think!)
Teachers are not brain surgeons--we are much more important...
Teachers are not brain surgeons. I sometimes wish we were. Surgeons get paid a lot, and surgeons get to feel like they're DOING something, get to feel like there is a clear problem and they are going to fix it. Plus, their job is a lot easier than the jobs of regular doctors or of teachers, because they don't have to deal with difficult people. The people they deal with are easy to deal with, because they are asleep.
While we teachers may wish we had anaesthetists to put our students to sleep before we worked on them, and while we may wish that what made the difference was the actions we ourselves did directly, rather than those we helped other people do, our lives are not so simple.
A lot of teacher discourse sounds like we are like surgeons, focusing on what the teacher does to, not with, the students, just as much of the discourse about reading education avoids the term "reading" and relies heavily on terms like "instruction", "skills", "strategies", and so on. These terms--like the term "teaching" itself--make it sound like we are either conveying information in a gradgrindian way (filling little vessels with facts!) or else instructing children in a step-by-step process, as if we are ambulatory instruction manuals.
But English teachers are not instruction manuals. What's ironic is that just as teachers in other disciplines are getting away from "instruction" by, for instance, flipping the classroom, so that the teacher works instead as a coach, we English teachers, who arguably have less to "teach" than teachers in "the content areas", are constantly being told about "instruction."
Why would we want to be instruction manuals? Instruction manuals don't actually work very well, because most people don't like to use them. Most instruction manuals, like the one in the John Ashbery poem, lead not to understanding, but to our dreaming of Guadalajara, or of some other place we have never been.
Teachers are neither surgeons, operating directly on the brains of etherized students, nor ambulatory instruction manuals, mechanically dispensing information. We are people dealing with other people, and the important things we do are to create conditions in which kids will want to read and write, and to help kids pay attention to their own reading and writing. This may involve instruction, but often it does not.
Relationship before task
I once peeked at the "Course Expectations" a wise colleague of mine was handing out on the first day of the year. My colleague told his students that when people were doing difficult tasks, studies had shown that they could do them better and longer if there were only another person in the room. His goal that year, he had written to his students, was to be, for them, that "other person in the room."
I thought about my colleague's words when I was talking with my wife the other day. My wife has been doing a fair amount of SAT tutoring recently, and she tells me that parents often talk as if what she will be doing with their children is sharing with them the "strategies" and "tricks" that she learned in her time as a high-achieving student at ivy league colleges and her stints as a college instructor at elite universities. The truth is, she said, that when she and her students work on the reading sections of the SAT, what she mainly does is sit with the students while the students figure it out for themselves. What I really do, she said, is to help them to see their own thought processes. In order to help them do so, she needs to build a strong relationship with the student--so she always spends some time chatting with her students about what's important to them, what's going on in their lives.
My department chair is right to be fond of the dictum, "Relationship before task." The task is the responsibility of the students; the relationship is our responsibility.
Building Relationships (more wise colleagues!)
As these guidelines may show, our wise colleagues encouraged us to detach ourselves from our annoyance, see our students with compassion, and use these sometimes-difficult moments to build stronger human relationships with our students. To illustrate their wisdom, our colleagues told a few stories and showed us some video they had taken.
One wonderful story was this: when one of these colleagues was a student teacher, she went with her mentor teacher and their students on an overnight trip early in the year. At a certain point late in the night, one student went missing. The mentor teacher was annoyed and upset, and clearly, said my colleague, angry with the student who had slipped away. When they finally found the student, my colleague expected her mentor teacher to light into the kid, or at least show that she was upset. Instead, she told us, the master teacher opened her arms, gave the kid a huge hug, and said, "We were so worried about you!" For my colleague, this was an eye-opening experience--and as she told the story, we were right there with her. A good teacher doesn't let her students off the hook, but always shows that she cares about them. If she doesn't, they won't learn. According to my colleague, that kid, who was going through a difficult time, had a good relationship with her teachers for the rest of the year.
The video that our colleagues shared was also really interesting. The clips we watched were only a minute or two each, but it was amazing how much was happening in those minutes. I've never seen so clearly how a good teacher can have a dozen meaningful interactions, with a dozen different students, in the course of only a minute or two. A look, a wave, a few words--each time this happened, a relationship was strengthened and a student was helped to, as my wife says, see his or her own thought process. My colleagues were holding up a mirror--a compassionate mirror--to their students, and their students clearly felt supported, cared for, and encouraged.
Not brain surgeons, not instructors, but people!
These colleagues have also spent a lot of time working together on planning classroom activities (how to introduce books, how to facilitate discussions, structures for bringing out responses and helping students to organize their thinking, etc.), but very little of what they do is what I would call "instruction". They are not brain surgeons, not instruction manuals, but people, helping other people.
Teachers are not brain surgeons--we are much more important...
Teachers are not brain surgeons. I sometimes wish we were. Surgeons get paid a lot, and surgeons get to feel like they're DOING something, get to feel like there is a clear problem and they are going to fix it. Plus, their job is a lot easier than the jobs of regular doctors or of teachers, because they don't have to deal with difficult people. The people they deal with are easy to deal with, because they are asleep.
While we teachers may wish we had anaesthetists to put our students to sleep before we worked on them, and while we may wish that what made the difference was the actions we ourselves did directly, rather than those we helped other people do, our lives are not so simple.
A lot of teacher discourse sounds like we are like surgeons, focusing on what the teacher does to, not with, the students, just as much of the discourse about reading education avoids the term "reading" and relies heavily on terms like "instruction", "skills", "strategies", and so on. These terms--like the term "teaching" itself--make it sound like we are either conveying information in a gradgrindian way (filling little vessels with facts!) or else instructing children in a step-by-step process, as if we are ambulatory instruction manuals.
But English teachers are not instruction manuals. What's ironic is that just as teachers in other disciplines are getting away from "instruction" by, for instance, flipping the classroom, so that the teacher works instead as a coach, we English teachers, who arguably have less to "teach" than teachers in "the content areas", are constantly being told about "instruction."
Why would we want to be instruction manuals? Instruction manuals don't actually work very well, because most people don't like to use them. Most instruction manuals, like the one in the John Ashbery poem, lead not to understanding, but to our dreaming of Guadalajara, or of some other place we have never been.
Teachers are neither surgeons, operating directly on the brains of etherized students, nor ambulatory instruction manuals, mechanically dispensing information. We are people dealing with other people, and the important things we do are to create conditions in which kids will want to read and write, and to help kids pay attention to their own reading and writing. This may involve instruction, but often it does not.
Relationship before task
I once peeked at the "Course Expectations" a wise colleague of mine was handing out on the first day of the year. My colleague told his students that when people were doing difficult tasks, studies had shown that they could do them better and longer if there were only another person in the room. His goal that year, he had written to his students, was to be, for them, that "other person in the room."
I thought about my colleague's words when I was talking with my wife the other day. My wife has been doing a fair amount of SAT tutoring recently, and she tells me that parents often talk as if what she will be doing with their children is sharing with them the "strategies" and "tricks" that she learned in her time as a high-achieving student at ivy league colleges and her stints as a college instructor at elite universities. The truth is, she said, that when she and her students work on the reading sections of the SAT, what she mainly does is sit with the students while the students figure it out for themselves. What I really do, she said, is to help them to see their own thought processes. In order to help them do so, she needs to build a strong relationship with the student--so she always spends some time chatting with her students about what's important to them, what's going on in their lives.
My department chair is right to be fond of the dictum, "Relationship before task." The task is the responsibility of the students; the relationship is our responsibility.
Building Relationships (more wise colleagues!)
In today's department meeting, we were treated to a presentation by a couple of our colleagues who have been systematically investigating the ways in which they build relationships with their students. Relationships with students, they said, are built through the many small moments, the micro-interactions, that we have each day with individual students. They offered a set of helpful guidelines for handling these little moments, many of which may present themselves to us as difficult or annoying. Many of these guidelines were familiar from parenting books I've found helpful in dealing with my own kids at home (acknowledge, validate, try non-verbal response, give benefit of the doubt, start with observation, not judgment, offer student choice to provide solution, etc.), but I realized that I hadn't given much conscious thought to how they applied to dealing with students, and it was helpful to have them made explicit.
As these guidelines may show, our wise colleagues encouraged us to detach ourselves from our annoyance, see our students with compassion, and use these sometimes-difficult moments to build stronger human relationships with our students. To illustrate their wisdom, our colleagues told a few stories and showed us some video they had taken.
One wonderful story was this: when one of these colleagues was a student teacher, she went with her mentor teacher and their students on an overnight trip early in the year. At a certain point late in the night, one student went missing. The mentor teacher was annoyed and upset, and clearly, said my colleague, angry with the student who had slipped away. When they finally found the student, my colleague expected her mentor teacher to light into the kid, or at least show that she was upset. Instead, she told us, the master teacher opened her arms, gave the kid a huge hug, and said, "We were so worried about you!" For my colleague, this was an eye-opening experience--and as she told the story, we were right there with her. A good teacher doesn't let her students off the hook, but always shows that she cares about them. If she doesn't, they won't learn. According to my colleague, that kid, who was going through a difficult time, had a good relationship with her teachers for the rest of the year.
The video that our colleagues shared was also really interesting. The clips we watched were only a minute or two each, but it was amazing how much was happening in those minutes. I've never seen so clearly how a good teacher can have a dozen meaningful interactions, with a dozen different students, in the course of only a minute or two. A look, a wave, a few words--each time this happened, a relationship was strengthened and a student was helped to, as my wife says, see his or her own thought process. My colleagues were holding up a mirror--a compassionate mirror--to their students, and their students clearly felt supported, cared for, and encouraged.
Not brain surgeons, not instructors, but people!
These colleagues have also spent a lot of time working together on planning classroom activities (how to introduce books, how to facilitate discussions, structures for bringing out responses and helping students to organize their thinking, etc.), but very little of what they do is what I would call "instruction". They are not brain surgeons, not instruction manuals, but people, helping other people.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)